JSESD001: Land Tenure and Neo Customary Commodification Practices in Seke and Domboshava Communal Peri-Urban Areas, Zimbabwe
Keywords:
commodification, communal peri-urban areas, compensation, land tenure, neo-customary commodificationAbstract
In Zimbabwe, rural areas close to large cities – communal peri-urban
areas – operate under customary land tenure. Urbanites are scrambling for
this cheaper land through illegal subdivisions and sales despite the legal
provisions of the Communal Land Act (Chapter 20:04). Literature describes
this process as ‘neo-customary commodification’, or Operation Garawadya
Panotorwa Mahara (enjoy the benefit before it is reversed and land is taken for
free), in colloquial Shona. This article, focussing on Seke and Domboshava
in Zimbabwe, seeks to examine transformations in customary land tenure
in communal peri-urban areas. It also unpacks the capacity, prospects and
precincts of the existing institutional and legal frameworks of the land tenure
system. The adopted mixed methods approach consists of surveys in Seke and
Dombosahava, and key informant interviews with respective Rural District
Council officials and traditional leaders. The article establishes centrifugal
and centripetal factors catalysing the neo-commodification practices,
including legal pluralism, flouting of the land allocation system in communal
peri-urban areas, communal peri-urban landholder disgruntlement with the
vesting of communal land in the State, lack of compensation for communal
peri-urban land excised for urban development, and the tragedy of the
commons. To address these issues, this study recommends the formulation
of a new comprehensive land policy informed by ongoing policy reviews.
The new policy should ideally include divestiture of communal land from
State ownership to communal land trusts. The study also recommends the
formulation of a responsive compensation policy to improve outcomes for
communal landholders after excision of land for urban development, and
the development of a comprehensive spatial planning policy that declares
communal peri-urban zones as special development zones. Such policy
measures for communal peri-urban areas would facilitate the gradual
transformation of communal land rights, and promote proper land-use
planning and the emergence of a proper legal market in Zimbabwe’s
communal peri-urban areas.